Does Paul Wolfowitz Not Know How Many American Soldiers Have Died in Iraq?

"It's approximately 500, of which - I can get the exact numbers - approximately 350 are combat deaths."
--Deputy Defense Secretary Paul Wolfowitz, asked about American casualties at a hearing of a House Appropriations subcommittee in April.

A question in light of Memorial Day: which is more likely, that Wolfowitz didn't know how many Americans had died in Iraq, or simply didn't care?


The Historical Origins of a Comic Strip

Do you remember the comic strip "Calvin and Hobbes"? Did you know that John Calvin and Thomas Hobbes were basically opposed on the roles of government and religion?

Calvin essentially argued for a theocracy - government ruled by the church. Hobbes felt that religion should be controlled by the state.
Calvin argues for two types of government in his compendium of theology, "The Institutes of the Christian Religion." One government rules the spiritual or inward aspect of humanity, that is, spiritual government, and one government rules the external aspects of human life, that is, secular government.

Calvin was a strong believer in behaving as God wished. Immorality was severely condemned but to begin with the consistory was not an effective body. It only started to be so when the number of appointed ministers was greater than the elders. Also in 1555, the city council gave the consistory the right to excommunicate offenders. Only after this date was a strict moral code imposed and every sin was made a crime e.g. no work or pleasure on a Sunday; no extravagance in dress. If you were excommunicated you were banished from the city. Blasphemy could be punished by death; lewd singing could be punished by your tongue being pierced.
Thomas Hobbes
Fear of things invisible is the natural seed of that which everyone in himself calleth religion. - Leviathan

Hobbes is famous for his early and elaborate development of what has come to be known as “social contract theory”, the method of justifying political principles or arrangements by appeal to the agreement that would be made among suitably situated rational, free, and equal persons.
Do what?!

Gore speaks. Ashcroft says - "Hey, look over there".
Random thought on forced democracy

I heard a terrible Michael Jackson song on the radio ("Man in the Mirror") while watching CNN news about how the US was trying to "teach" the Iraqis how to have a democracy that was representative of the vast cultural diversity of the nation. The juxtaposition gave me pause.

Currently in the US of A, women hold only 12 percent of the seats in Congress, a lower percentage than such nations as Mexico and South Africa. Ethnic minorities are even more severely under-represented. Women also fare poorly in executive offices. Forty seven of 50 states have male governors, and 24 of our largest 25 cities have male mayors. (These stats are from 2000.)

I don't believe one always has to practice what one preaches. To carry the religio metaphor further, classic Christian doctrine tells everyone to be more like Jesus while acknowledging that nobody ever will reach that goal so they can't ever practice what they... but I digress. The point is, I do think that one has more credibility when doing what one tells others to do. And this brings me to the more general question derived from the above: should we be convincing others to do it our way (or at least the way we wish we did it)?

I've never really bought into the whole idea that US democracy is the beacon on the hill, but I do think our system of government works pretty well for us. Why is it that we think it will work well for others? Should the whole world use the same system of governance? That loss of diversity is decried in biology, in linguistics, and in almost every other area of thought/research I can think of. Why is everyone (well, at least the US) so hyped up about crushing every alternative political system? The claim is hollow given our support of various authoritarian regimes when it serves our economic interests, but we certainly claim to have the aim of global free-market democracy. Who are we to tell people they can't live in a Theocracy or Dictatorship? Is liberation the new imperialism? (I hear that orange is the new black this season...)

Maybe the answer is to find a new radio station that doesn't play Michael Jackson songs.
Christianity as State-Craft (What is it good for, absolutely nothing...Say it again)

No matter how you define the war on terror, I believe that present problems stem from Bush's "crusade for freedom and democracy" and the decidedly Fundamentalist Christian agenda that guides foreign policy. (A note to the discerning reader; I believe a very real distinction exists between Christianity and God. One is fundamentally exclusive of the other. So before lightning striketh me down, I'd like to point out that my concern is with Christianity, not with God. That was close...) Christianity inherently pits right against wrong, believers against non-believers and the chosen few against everyone else. It constructs the world into convenient dichotomies.

And therein lies the problem. By adhering to a polarity that stipulates that it's our way or not, we naturally fall into a tendency to create hierarchies that place us on the side of right. In the past, attitudes such as this led to things like slavery and Hitler's racial cleansing.

Thus goes my argument: we're wrong, and Bush's dogmatic Christianity is the reason that our foreign policies, wrought with spiritual rhetoric, display inherent kinks. Bush thinks his America is fundamentally better in all aspects, including political organization and collective spirituality. Now, don't get me wrong, I love my country. But I don't want to convey any sentiment of superiority to anyone.

I recently picked up a book by Samuel Wilson. It's called The Emperor's Giraffe and Other Stories of Cultures in Contact. One passage stuck with me. It states that this notion of dominance and superiority is one that permeates history, and it's been the justification for countless abominations against human-kind. I'd like to share it with you:

"In the early laws in Virginia and Massachusetts...Biblical passages were quoted as justification for the appropriation of land: 'And of me, I shall give thee the heathen for thine inheritance, and the uttermost parts of the earth for thy possession' (Psalms 2:8); and 'Whosoever, therefore, resisteth the power, resisteth the ordinance of God; and they that resist shall receive to themselves damnation' (Romans 13:2). A contemporary satirist put it succinctly in a supposed summary of a puritan town meeting : 'Voted, that the earth is the Lord's and the fulness thereof; Voted, that the earth is given to the Saints; Voted, that we are the Saints'" (Wilson 1999:94).

Here we are once again. The chosen few against the heathen, the lovers of freedom against the enemies thereof, us versus the evil doers, and the politically and socially enlightened against the enemies of democracy.

My brothers and sisters, Christianity as a state religion will only bring more violence. Christianity as the basis for state-craft only breeds delusions of moral grandeur that in turn lead to war. Our founding fathers foresaw this, believe it or not, and in their infinite wisdom they identified a solution; it's called the separation of church and state. If you disagree with my argument, check your history...I'm sure I'll be vindicated.
Thank God for the (Military) Republicans!
Part 3 in a series


If you missed 60 Minutes last night, you missed Steve Kroft's interview with retired Marine General Anthony Zinni, former head of the US Central Command and a special envoy to the Middle East, and a registered Republican.
"In the lead up to the Iraq war and its later conduct, I saw at a minimum, true dereliction, negligence and irresponsibility, at worse, lying, incompetence and corruption."

“I believe that they [Rumsfeld and Wolfowitz] should accept responsibility for that. If I were the commander of a military organization that delivered this kind of performance to the president, I certainly would tender my resignation. I certainly would expect to be gone.”

“It is part of your duty. Look, there is one statement that bothers me more than anything else. And that's the idea that when the troops are in combat, everybody has to shut up. Imagine if we put troops in combat with a faulty rifle, and that rifle was malfunctioning, and troops were dying as a result."
Zinni endorsed Bush in 2000, but has compared Iraq war strategy to a "brain fart" emitted from a Bush "policy wonk."
Thank God for the Republicans!
Part 2 in a series


This story didn't get much local coverage, and none that I know of on the national level, but I think it's significant and speaks for itself:
Kerry gets help from rival party in Marin

$80,000 raised at Tiburon event

By Richard Halstead, IJ reporter

A group of Marin Republicans turned off by President Bush's performance joined with Democratic supporters of John Kerry at a rally in Tiburon last night, which raised more than $80,000 for Kerry's campaign.

"You understand that the ultimate test of freedom is the removal of an incumbent who is not doing the job that ought to be done," Allan Littman, one of the rally's Republican organizers, told the more than 200 people, who attended the rally at the Tiburon Peninsula Club.

Littman, a former Tiburon councilman, is one of four Republicans on the 10-member steering committee of the newly founded Tiburon Peninsula Bipartisan Committee for John Kerry. Each steering committee member donated $2,000 to the Kerry campaign last night.
In other news, John McCain demonstrated that not all Republicans support Bush's cynical and deceptive tax cuts during a time of war.
"From pork-barrel spending to expanding entitlements to tax cuts for the wealthiest citizens, both parties have proven who they are working for and it's not the American taxpayer. My friends, we are at war. Throughout our history, wartime has been a time of sacrifice."

"I fondly remember a time when real Republicans stood for fiscal responsibility. Apparently, those days are long gone for some in our party."
House Speaker Dennis Hastert, R-Ill., responded by impugning McCain's patriotism. "If you want to see sacrifice, John McCain ought to visit our young men and women at Walter Reed and Bethesda. There's the sacrifice in this country." A Republican chickenhawk attacking a decorated veteran's patriotism reminded me of the attacks leveled against Max Cleland in 2002.
Thank God for the Republicans!
Part 1 in a series


I've been saying it for weeks now: no group is doing more damage to the Bush administration right now than themselves and old school Republicans.

The Democrats have been given ample opportunity to call Bush to task, but they've lacked the courage to do much more than whine and moan. Defacto Democratic Presidential nominee John Kerry has been strangely quiet lately, letting Karl Rove define the terms of the debate, barely defending himself against the GOP's spurious attacks on his combat service record. (Arianna Huffington and others have called on Kerry to "go big, ask more from us, and power his campaign on the politics of hope and progress." If you agree, sign the petition.)

While the Democrats work on figuring out ways to lose in November, thanks should go out to stand-up Republicans like Paul O'Neill, Richard Clarke, John Dean, Joseph Wilson, Bob Woodward, Patrick Buchanan, John McCain .... Thanks to Republicans like these, each day we're learning more about Bush's lies and deceptions that led us into Iraq, and the damage he is doing to democracy at home and abroad.

Tell your Republican friends and family. They may listen to you, but they're much more likely to listen to members of their own party.
Michael Moore's Fahrenheit 9/11 World Premiere on Monday
Moore revealed he had smuggled three camera crews into Iraq to film disillusioned US soldiers for his new documentary, Fahrenheit 9/11.

He was speaking for the first time since his public row with Disney, who had refused to distribute the film in the US because of its anti-Bush message.

Fahrenheit 9/11 looks at life in the US in the wake of the 11 September 2001 attacks and the onset of military action in Afghanistan and Iraq.

Moore sent the crews into Iraq after disaffected soldiers wrote to him, he said.

"I was able to sneak three different freelance crews into Iraq," he said.

The soldiers had "express disillusionment that they had been lied to", said Moore.

"[The film from Iraq] is certainly something the Bush administration does not want people to see," said Moore.

Moore made Fahrenheit 9/11 for Miramax, which is owned by Disney.

He said Disney had backed out of distributing the film for "only political reasons".
This isn't the first time that Moore has been muzzled. HarperCollins asked him to excise 50 pages from "Stupid White Men," in which he was critical of President Bush, just after 9/11. Moore refused. Harper pushed back the release date, sitting on 50,000 finished books. The only reason why the book was finally released as Moore had intended was that a librarian stood up for him.
"This is a fascinating story because it shows what a free society does when confronted with a crisis. Do we maintain our sense of freedom and liberty and dissent and open discussion of the issues? Or do we start putting the clamp down?"
Once the book became a bestseller, Moore was ticked off that he had made so much money for a corporation that didn't have the balls to defend him. He's now with a new publisher and "Dude, Where's My Country" has been a big success.

That was two years ago. Now we have even more reason to criticize Bush, while yet another corporation, Disney, is unwilling to advance Moore's work, even when it's certain to bring them profits.

I don't see the same sort of timidity when Ann Coulter or Bill O'Reilly come out with new books. Gosh, I wonder why?

As consumers, we can only hope that Disney shareholders punish their board for its political timidity.

Scenes are available at Moore's website here.

* * *


This story of Disney cowering to rightwing political pressure reminds me of what they did to Bill Maher in 2001.

On the first episode of "Politically Incorrect" after 9/11, guest Dinesh D'Souza told host Maher that Bush was wrong for calling the attackers "cowards."
'Not true,' D'Souza said. 'Look at what they did. First of all, you have a whole bunch of guys who are willing to give their life. None of 'em backed out. All of them slammed themselves into pieces of concrete.'

Maher concurred. 'We have been the cowards lobbing cruise missiles from 2,000 miles away,' he said. 'That's cowardly. Staying in the airplane when it hits the building, say what you want about it, it's not cowardly'
Ok, big deal, the show is called Politically Incorrect, right? But then Texas-based radio-show host Dan Patrick told his listeners to complain to both Sears and FedEx, who both subsequently pulled their advertising from the show.

Maher later issued a clarification and apologized, but the damage was done.

ABC's Washington, D.C., affiliate WJLA -- along with 16 other stations -- decided to drop the show.

Then the White House joined the fray when Ari Fleischer said Maher's comments were: "'unfortunate' and 'a terrible thing to say.' Although he hadn't actually seen the broadcast, Fleischer said it was a reminder that Americans 'need to watch what they say, watch what they do, and this is not a time for remarks like that; there never is.'"

Sounds Orwellian, doesn't it? Guess what all the controversy did for Maher's ratings? "The controversy has boosted Politically Incorrect to its best ratings in more than six months. The show averaged 2.8 million viewers for the week of September 17, up 20 percent from last year."

So what did Disney/ABC do? It took them until May 2002, but they finally fired Maher.
ABC Chairman Lloyd Braun said Maher's controversial comments had nothing to do with the decision to replace him.

'We made a decision to go with straight entertainment programming in late night,' Braun said on Tuesday. 'That's just basically a scheduling opportunity that we felt over the long term had more potential.'

Whereas Disney executives often publicly supported Koppel and 'Nightline' after the Letterman flap, there was little support for Maher and 'PI.'
HBO had the balls to give Maher a show, "Real Time with Bill Maher," and he's never been better. If you don't have HBO, get it by August, when he'll start his new season.

(Update: Michael Moore won the Palme d'Or. Boy, I can't wait to see this movie.)

Justice is Duck Blind!

The following is taken from Justice Scalia's memorandum rejecting the Sierra Club's request for him to recuse himself from the case involving Vice President Dick Cheney's secret energy task force meeting.
For five years or so, I have been going to Louisiana during the Court’s long December-January recess, to the duck-hunting camp of a friend whom I met through two hunting companions from Baton Rouge, one a dentist and the other a worker in the field of handicapped rehabilitation. The last three years, I have been accompanied on this trip by a son-in-law who lives near me. Our friend and host, Wallace Carline, has never, as far as I know, had business before this Court. He is not, as some reports have described him, an “energy industry executive” in the sense that summons up boardrooms of ExxonMobil or Con Edison. He runs his own company that provides services and equipment rental to oil rigs in the Gulf of Mexico.

During my December 2002 visit, I learned that Mr. Carline was an admirer of Vice President Cheney. Knowing that the Vice President, with whom I am well acquainted (from our years serving together in the Ford administration), is an enthusiastic duck-hunter, I asked whether Mr. Carline would like to invite him to our next year’s hunt. The answer was yes; I conveyed the invitation (with my own warm recommendation) in the spring of 2003 and received an acceptance (subject, of course, to any superseding demands on the Vice President’s time) in the summer. The Vice President said that if he did go, I would be welcome to fly down to Louisiana with him. (Because of national security requirements, of course, he must fly in a Government plane.) That invitation was later extended— if space was available—to my son-in-law and to a son who was joining the hunt for the first time; they accepted. The trip was set long before the Court granted certiorari in the present case, and indeed before the petition for certiorari had even been filed.

We departed from Andrews Air Force Base at about 10 a.m. on Monday, January 5, flying in a Gulfstream jet owned by the Government ...

Signs of Life

I don't know how much play this got on mainstream media, but it was on CNN at least once.
In the middle of Rumsfeld's testimony before the Senate Armed Services Committee today, a group of protesters let rip a pretty damn good chorus of "Fire Rumsfeld!" for about a minute before the cops ushered them out. Click here to see some quick video of the protesters from CNN's broadcast. (It's a 1.6 MB MPEG so give it time to download.)